It's Two Truths and a Lie Tuesday with Rascal Flatts!

People Country

By Danielle Anderson

06/24/2014 at 07:15 PM EDT

Joe Don Rooney, Gary LeVox and Jay DeMarcus of Rascal Flatts

Evan Agostini/Invision/AP

How well do you know Rascal Flatts? Probably not as well as you think! Joe Don Rooney, Gary LeVox and Jay DeMarcus recently played the classic get-to-know-you game of Two Truths and a Lie with us, and even we learned something new. Two of the below statements are true, one isn't. Can you guess the lie? Scroll down for the answer!

Joe Don Rooney has a super-sleuth mom.

Gary LeVox once stole a truck.

One time, Jay DeMarcus was asked to leave his dentist's office for unruly behavior.

Keep scrolling for the reveal!

Joe Don Rooney – True! "I got busted smoking and I didn't even have a cigarette in my hand, nor was I smoking a cigarette at the time," he explains to PEOPLE Country. "My mom and I were sitting on the front porch having a conversation. She said, 'You been smoking, haven't you?' I was 16. I said, 'No!' She goes, 'You have nicotine fingers!' I look down and there's this little orange line between my middle finger and my index finger. I was like, 'You busted me mom! I'm sorry!'"

Gary Levox – True! "I stole my dad's truck and I couldn't get it in gear, so it was stuck at the end of the road. I couldn't even bring it back because I couldn't figure out how to get it in reverse. I was 14 or 15," LeVox recalls. "My brother had called my dad and told him what I had done. As I'm walking back to the house, he's pulling in and it wasn't good."

Jay DeMarcus – Lie! DeMarcus is actually a dentist's dream. "I've never in my life had a cavity," he says. "Not one!"