Janel Parrish Reacts to Carrie Ann Inaba Saying She 'Gives Good Sex' (VIDEO)

Carrie Ann Inaba (left) and Janel Parrish and Val Chmerkovskiy

Adam Taylor/Getty

By Tim Nudd

@nudd

09/30/2014 AT 03:40 PM EDT

It was meant to be a compliment. No, really.

Carrie Ann Inaba was blown away, as all the judges were, by Janel Parrish and Val Chmerkovskiy's amazing, jazzy send-up of West Side Story during Monday's episode of Dancing with the Stars .

But during the critique afterward, Inaba's phrasing got a little strange, as she told the Pretty Little Liars star, in the midst of an otherwise professional review, that she "gives good sex."

The audience laughed, and Inaba quickly backtracked. But how did Parrish and Chmerkovskiy feel about that?

PEOPLE caught up with them after the show, where Parrish, 25, was giving Inaba the benefit of the doubt – though Chmerkovskiy, 28, seemed more skeptical.

Check out the Inaba's full commentary and their response in the video below, so you can judge for yourself.