Watch Andy Samberg and Jimmy Fallon Crack Each Other Up with '5-Second Summaries' (VIDEO)

09/25/2014 AT 09:15 AM EDT

There's really nothing better than two cute, funny guys making each other laugh, right?

Andy Samberg sat down with Jimmy Fallon on The Tonight Show Wednesday night, and the two former Saturday Night Live pals got right back up to their old tricks, splitting sides with a routine called "Five-Second Summaries," where they have – you guessed it – five seconds to summarize the plot of a movie to the point where the other can guess it.

And if you think some Wheel of Fortune guesses are impressive, wait until you see Fallon guess Honey, I Shrunk the Kids from Samberg's summary: "I'm in the Cheerios."

Samberg's prize for winning? Burgers for the entire Brooklyn Nine-Nine crew on Fallon's dime. The beloved cop show, its cast now amped up for free Fallon-burgers, returns to Fox on Sunday, Sept. 28.

Check out the full "Five-Second Summaries" clip below.