Which Stars Actually Ate Ellen's Oscars Pizza?

By Nate Jones

03/02/2014 at 11:25 PM EST

Ellen DeGeneres (left) and actor Jared Leto at the 2014 Oscars

Kevin Winter/Getty

It's like Chekhov always said: Never make a joke about giving pizza to celebrities in the first act if you're not going to actually give the celebrities pizza in the third act.

Ellen DeGeneres's original joke about ordering pizza to the Hollywood & Highland Center was an enjoyably silly bit of Oscars fluff – that she actually followed through with it was the stuff of genius.

Below, a list of the stars who threw aside their fear of tomato sauce to nosh on Ellen's pizza (and the ones who refrained):

Julia Roberts: Took a slice.

Meryl Streep: Took two slices, one for herself and one for her husband.

Brad Pitt: Handed out plates, then took a slice.

Kevin Spacey: Handed out plates.

Dax Shepard: Took a slice.

Jared Leto: Took a slice for his mom.

Jennifer Lawrence: Took a slice.

Leonardo DiCaprio: Did not take a slice.

Harrison Ford: Took a slice.

Corinne Fox, Channing Tatum and Jenna Dewan Tatum: Each took a slice.

Kerry Washington: Looked like she really wanted a slice, but did not get one.

Follow PEOPLE on Facebook!